2 1 discussion nature vs nurture endures

The evolution of the field of developmental psychology has begun to trend toward a more holistic view of development, and this is evidenced by the theories of hereditary and environmental interaction. On the surface, these theories appear to be challenging the nature versus nurture controversy by acknowledging that each is necessary and integral to development. Upon closer review, we find that the controversy endures as each theory appears to favor one over the other within the theory. Select one of the following heredity and environmental interaction theories that you believe provides the most valid explanation for the interaction of nature and nurture, provide a brief explanation of the theory in your own words, and clearly state which side of the nature versus nurture controversy you believe is favored by this theory.

Get Your Custom Essay Written From Scratch
We have worked on a similar problem. If you need help click order now button and submit your assignment instructions.
Just from $13/Page
Order Now
  • The canalization principle
  • The range-of-reaction principle
  • Genotype/environment correlations

In response to your peers, debate their position regarding the theory’s position on nature versus nurture, and challenge their selection as compared to your own regarding its position as the most valid of the three theories.

To complete this assignment, review the Discussion Rubric document.

AFTER COMPLETING THE INITIAL POST, PLEASE ALSO RESPND TO THE FOLLOWING TWO STUDENTS REGARDING THE SAME TOPIC!


STUDENT ONE:

Kentucky Fried Chicken

The real-life story of Colonel Harland Sanders who was disappointed umpteen times in his life and still made his dream come true late in his life is really inspiring.

He is a seventh grade dropped out who tried many ventures in life but tasted bitter every time. He started selling chicken at his age of 40 but his dream of a restaurant was turned down many times due to conflicts and wars.

Later he attempted to franchise his restaurant. His recipe got rejected 1,009 times before the final approval. And soon the secret recipe, “Kentucky Fried Chicken” became a huge hit worldwide. KFC was expanded globally and the company was sold for 2 million dollars and his face is still celebrated in the logos.

Moral: Have you stopped your attempts to a venture just because you were rejected or failed a few times? Can you even accept a failure of 1009 times? This story inspires everyone to try hard and believe in yourself until you see success despite how many times you have failed.

STUDENT TWO:

The Canalization Principle makes the most sense when trying to combine two different theories on why people develop the way they do, and what influences that development. According to Shaffer & Kipp (2014) canalization principle is rooted in three principle ideas; that there are multiple pathways that one can go, that nature and nurture combine to make that pathway and that either genes or environment can limit the extent the other factor plays a part in the pathway. Because there is a combination of the nature/nurture principle it makes the most sense. This principle does propose that high degree of canalization does cancel out the environmental factor that plays a part in development. This is based on the usual maturing of people. The less canalized relates to traits such as personality, intelligence and temperament, relating it to experiences that the person has had. This too is related to if the environment is too extreme such as domestic violence, that a child will not continue to develop naturally or mature the biological way that they should. This has resulted in the fact that the environment took over the natural pathway the child should have matured.

Shaffer, D., Kipp, K. (2014). Developmental psychology. Childhood & Adolescence. 9th Edition. Wadsworth Cengage Learning. California, USA.

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.